Buyer's Guide

The Short List: Evaluation Bordeaux's 2025 Vintage

Bordeaux · · 61 wines

This year, I went to Bordeaux twice to taste the 2025 vintage. On my first visit, in April, we dove into a series of en primeur tastings throughout the Left and Right Banks. I returned in June just in time to experience a historic heat wave (and relished the time I spent in cool cellars). 


I visited Smith Haut Lafitte, Domaine de Chevalier, Margaux, Ducru-Beaucaillou, Lynch-Bages, Duhart-Milon, Lafite Rothschild, Mouton Rothschild, Cheval Blanc, Vieux Château Certan, de Pressac, La Gaffelière, Carbonnieux, Vignobles de Larose, Kirwan, and de Malleret. This extended online version includes summaries of each estate, along with reviews of more wines tasted during my visits, including from other vintages.


View the original article online from the November/December 2026 issue of The Tasting Panel here. Scroll down to learn about the producers and to see the ratings and scores for each.


Château Carbonnieux

Carbonnieux traces its history back eight centuries. Marc Perrin bought the property in 1956, beginning four generations of family stewardship. The vineyard covers about 100 hectares around the château, on a gravel rise that helps explain the estate’s equal footing in reds and whites. Both colors are classified in the Graves. The whites, built on Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon, have the freshness to drink young and the structure to develop in bottle. The reds take their shape from Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot.

Château Cheval Blanc

The modern estate took shape from 1832 through acquisitions that included land from Figeac. Bernard Arnault and Albert Frère bought it in 1998. Formerly Premier Grand Cru Classé A, Cheval Blanc announced in 2021 that it would not participate in the 2022 classification. Pierre-Olivier Clouet directs, with Pierre Lurton chairing the board. Clay and gravel, Merlot and Cabernet Franc: perfumed, seamless wines. The estate reports historically low yields of 15 hl/ha in 2025; no Petit Cheval red was produced.

Château Clerc Milon

Baron Philippe de Rothschild bought Clerc Milon in 1970 and set about restoring it. The 41-hectare vineyard lies in a single sweep on the Mousset outcrop, overlooking the Gironde between two First Growth properties. Gravel and sand over a clay-limestone base give the estate room to work with several traditional Bordeaux varieties. Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot lead the blend, with a small amount of Carmenère among the estate’s distinguishing features. Clerc Milon combines the firmness of Pauillac with a generous middle palate.

Château d'Armailhac

Known as Mouton-d’Armailhacq at the time of the 1855 classification, the estate was acquired by Baron Philippe de Rothschild in 1933. It passed to his daughter Philippine and now sits alongside Mouton Rothschild and Clerc Milon in the family’s Pauillac portfolio. The vineyard stretches across three gravel banks, with about 80 hectares planted. Cabernet Sauvignon gives the wine its frame, while Merlot and Cabernet Franc help shape its fruit and perfume. The estate’s new production facilities give the team more scope to work parcel by parcel.

Château d’Yquem

Yquem was the sole Sauternes estate ranked Premier Cru Supérieur in 1855. The Sauvage and Lur-Saluces families shaped its history before LVMH acquired the property in 1999. Pierre Lurton serves as president, with Lorenzo Pasquini appointed general manager in 2025. Pickers pass through the vineyard repeatedly, selecting Sémillon and Sauvignon Blanc as noble rot concentrates individual berries. The balance of richness and freshness is the estate’s signature. The 2021, 2022 and 2023 vintages reviewed here show how differently that balance can play out from year to year.

Château de Malleret

The modern history of Château de Malleret dates to 1860. The property in Le Pian-Médoc is known for its horses as well as its vineyards, which occupy several well-drained parcels with distinct soils. A separate plot of roughly 3.5 hectares in Margaux is planted entirely to Merlot and bottled under that appellation. Paul Bordes arrived as manager in 2013, bringing changes in the vineyard that included a return to hand harvesting. The resulting range lets visitors compare the estate’s Haut-Médoc and Margaux holdings side by side.

Château de Pressac

The estate associates its château with the surrender following the Battle of Castillon in 1453. Noir de Pressac—the local name for Malbec—was planted here between 1737 and 1747. Jean-François and Dominique Quenin bought the property in 1997; Grand Cru Classé status followed in 2012. Its 41 hectares of vines span limestone plateau, clay-limestone slopes and sandy-clay soils below. In the cellar, selected lots undergo whole-cluster fermentation, with berries and bunches layered together. The 2025 combines concentrated fruit and velvety texture with substantial tannic grip.

Château Ducru Beaucaillou

The estate traces its history to 1720; Bertrand Ducru acquired it in 1797, adding his name to Beaucaillou, a reference to its “beautiful stones.” The Borie family’s stewardship began through a tenancy in 1942 and continues under third-generation Bruno-Eugène Borie. Stony gravel provides the setting for powerful yet refined Saint-Julien. La Croix Ducru-Beaucaillou and Le Petit Ducru offer other expressions of the estate’s Saint-Julien vineyards; Madame de Beaucaillou comes from the family’s Haut-Médoc holdings.

Château Duhart-Milon

Domaines Barons de Rothschild (Lafite) acquired Duhart-Milon in 1962. Éric Kohler oversees technical operations here and at neighboring Lafite. The vineyard occupies the Milon hillside, extending the Carruades plateau, with sandy gravel and varying amounts of clay. Duhart is the quieter Rothschild Pauillac: savory, structured and ageworthy, with a firm backbone and measured fruit.

Chateau Haut Batailley

The Tour l’Aspic marks Haut-Batailley at the southern entrance to Pauillac. The vineyard took its current identity in 1942 when Batailley was divided into two properties. The Cazes family, owners of Lynch-Bages and Ormes de Pez, acquired Haut-Batailley in 2017. Deep gravel suits Cabernet Sauvignon, with Merlot contributing breadth to the blend. Its position toward Saint-Julien is a useful point of reference for a wine that combines Pauillac structure with a more supple profile. Verso is the estate’s second wine.

Château Kirwan

Kirwan takes its name from the Irish family associated with the property in the 18th century. It was ranked a Third Growth in 1855, and the Schÿler family took over in 1926. The estate’s 37 hectares occupy a gravel-and-clay outcrop in Cantenac. Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot form the core of the blend, with Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot also planted. The gravel gives the wine its definition, while the clay helps explain its depth of fruit. The estate also bottles Charmes de Kirwan as its second wine.

Château La Gaffelière

The Malet Roquefort family’s estate spans limestone plateau, clay-rich slopes and sandy soils at the foot of the slopes, with some vines dating to the 1930s. Cabernet Franc accounts for roughly 35–40% of plantings, and the team wants more. Extraction follows the fruit rather than a fixed recipe, using punching down and rack-and-return; aging includes 50% new French oak. The wines bring perfume, concentrated fruit, chewy tannins and a long saline.

Château Lafite Rothschild

Lafite’s documented history reaches back to 1234. An original First Growth in the 1855 classification, it was bought by Baron James de Rothschild in 1868 and remains in the family. Saskia de Rothschild leads the family group, with Éric Kohler overseeing technical operations at Lafite and Duhart-Milon. Fine, deep gravel over limestone provides the foundation for wines that remain a reference for Pauillac elegance and longevity.

Château Lespault-Martillac

Lespault-Martillac is one of Martillac’s oldest vineyards, set on a gravel rise above the village. Since the 2009 vintage, the Bernard family’s Domaine de Chevalier team has run the estate. Merlot has an important place in the reds, alongside Cabernet Sauvignon, while Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon make up the white. The two colors show different sides of the site, with the reds drawing on Merlot for flesh and the whites on Sauvignon Blanc for lift. It remains a distinct property within the Bernard team’s Pessac-Léognan work.

Château Lynch-Bages

The estate dates Thomas Lynch’s acquisition through marriage to June 9, 1750. The Cazes family bought Lynch-Bages in 1939, and fourth-generation Jean-Charles Cazes now leads a group that includes Haut-Batailley and Ormes de Pez. Nicolas Labenne oversees viticulture and winemaking at Lynch-Bages and Ormes de Pez. Gravel soils frame a rich, generous expression of Pauillac, with graphite character and the structure to age.

Château Margaux

Pierre de Lestonnac reshaped the estate between 1572 and 1582. The property spans 265 hectares, roughly one-third devoted to vines. Thomas Jefferson ordered the 1784 vintage; Margaux became a First Growth in 1855. The Mentzelopoulos family has owned it since 1977. Corinne, daughter of André Mentzelopoulos, led for more than four decades before Alexis Leven-Mentzelopoulos became CEO in late 2023; Alexandra Petit-Mentzelopoulos chairs the holding company’s supervisory board. Philippe Bascaules returned as Managing Director in 2017. Gravel plateau; perfumed, silken, profound.

Château Mouton-Rothschild

Baron Nathaniel de Rothschild bought Brane-Mouton in 1853. Classified a Second Growth in 1855, it was promoted to First Growth in 1973. Philippe Sereys de Rothschild owns the estate with siblings Camille Sereys de Rothschild and Julien de Beaumarchais de Rothschild and serves as Chairman and CEO of Baron Philippe de Rothschild SA. Jean-Emmanuel Danjoy took technical responsibility for the family’s three Pauillac estates in 2020. Opulent, exotic and profound, Mouton brings its own expansive personality to Pauillac.

Chateau Ormes de Pez

Ormes de Pez has been part of the Médoc’s wine landscape since the 18th century and takes its name from the hamlet of Pez and the elms once associated with it. Jean-Charles Cazes bought the property in 1940, a year after the family acquired Lynch-Bages. Nicolas Labenne oversees viticulture and winemaking at both estates. Gravel and clay give the team scope to work with Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot. The latter brings flesh to a wine with the savory character and firm structure associated with Saint-Estèphe.

Château Puyblanquet

The Malet Roquefort family of Château La Gaffelière bought back Puyblanquet in 2020, returning it to the family after decades away. The vineyard lies at Saint-Étienne-de-Lisse on a clay-limestone slope, where its northerly exposure helps the fruit retain freshness. Merlot dominates the plantings, supported by Cabernet Franc and Cabernet Sauvignon. The combination of slope, exposure and limestone gives the wine its own shape within the family’s Saint-Émilion holdings. The 2020 marks the first vintage under the family’s renewed ownership.

Château Smith Haut Lafitte

Vineyards here date to the 14th century; the estate takes its name from Scottish merchant George Smith, who acquired it in the 18th century. Daniel and Florence Cathiard bought it in 1990 and transformed it. Daughters Mathilde Thomas and Alice Tourbier now head the executive board, with Florence on the supervisory board—a transition announced before Daniel’s death in January 2026. Managing Director Fabien Teitgen joined as vineyard manager in October 1995, becoming Technical Director six years later. Gravel soils underpin polished, complete reds and whites.

Cheval des Andes

Conceived in 1999, Cheval des Andes brings together Château Cheval Blanc and Terrazas de los Andes in Mendoza. Pierre Lurton and Roberto de la Mota explored the vineyards of Las Compuertas, where old Malbec offered the starting point for the project. Fruit from Las Compuertas and Altamira gives the team different sites to draw on, while Malbec and Cabernet Sauvignon form the core of the blend. The connection to Cheval Blanc is in the approach to blending and the emphasis on perfume, freshness and the capacity to age.

Clos des Lunes

Olivier Bernard of Domaine de Chevalier established Clos des Lunes in the Sauternes area in 2011, with dry white wine as the focus. Sémillon brings breadth and texture, while Sauvignon Blanc supplies lift. The grapes grow in country better known for its sweet wines, and the dry bottlings are sold as Bordeaux Blanc. The range runs from the early-drinking Lune Blanche through Lune d’Argent to Lune d’Or. Together they show how much shape and weight Sémillon can bring to a dry Bordeaux white.

Clos La Gaffelière

Clos La Gaffelière is the second wine of Château La Gaffelière, made by the Malet Roquefort family’s team. The estate’s technical notes point to the clay-rich foothills as a source for the wine, with Merlot leading and Cabernet Franc providing support. The team vinifies the selected lots separately before assembling the blend. Merlot brings the fruit and generosity, while Cabernet Franc contributes perfume and shape. The result offers an earlier-drinking view of the estate alongside the grand vin.

Domaine de Chevalier

Arnaud and Jean Ricard acquired and developed Domaine de Chevalier in 1865, building on a property with much older origins. The Bernard family bought it in 1983; Olivier Bernard leads, with Stéphane Derenoncourt consulting. Gravel soils provide the foundation for refined reds and long-lived whites, wines whose elegance never comes at the expense of depth. The family’s separate Clos des Lunes project brings the same interest in dry whites to the Sauternes area.

Domaine de la Solitude

The Community of the Holy Family owns Domaine de la Solitude, a 36-hectare vineyard southwest of Bordeaux. In 1993, the nuns entrusted its operation to the Bernard family’s Domaine de Chevalier team. The estate makes both red and white Pessac-Léognan, with Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot anchoring the reds and Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon joining forces in the whites. The two colors make a useful pair for understanding the breadth of the appellation and the Bernard team’s work across its different properties.

Vieux Château Certan

Among Pomerol’s oldest estates, Vieux Château Certan has roots in the 16th century and has carried its present name since 1745. Georges Thienpont bought it in 1924; Alexandre Thienpont took over in 1985, with his son Guillaume continuing the family’s vineyard and winemaking work. The clay-gravel plateau supports Merlot with a substantial Cabernet Franc presence. Finesse, depth and remarkable consistency define the wines.

Subscribe to see scores and full tasting notes.

Review tables locked

Subscribe to open Flip and Table modes with full notes and scores.

Subscribe