Article

The Short List: The Power and Polish of Bordeaux's 2025 Vintage

Evaluating Bordeaux’s 2025 Vintage

Jonathan Cristaldi · November 14, 2026

In this column, chief wine critic Jonathan Cristaldi selects a range of wines from portfolio tastings and sample submissions reviewed over the course of two months that make his “short list.” (The reviews are abbreviated in print but appear in full at tastingpanelmag.com/review.) Wines are assessed on a 100-point scale: Those achieving scores of 88–89 are very good; 90–94 are outstanding; and any within the 95–100 range represent prodigious efforts capable of long-term cellaring. Prices are for 750-milliliter bottles unless otherwise noted.

Subscriber access

You've used this month's free article

Subscribe once to read every Cristaldi report, Buyer's Guide, and tasting note across Tasting Panel and Somm Journal.